Rocpadz Drum Sets.

Ludwig Bass

The Myth of Controlled Drinking

For the past two decades, social psychologist Stanton Peele has questioned the necessity of abstinence for alcoholics, claiming, in The Meaning of Addiction and in Diseasing Of America: Addiction Treatment Out Of Conrol, that the “myth” of instant relapse is not well supported by statistical research.

Bulling his way past hundreds of published scientific studies about the neurobiology of addiction, Peele continues to insist that the disease concept of alcoholism has no basis in current science. Believing that people’s personal values determine whether or not they become addicts, Peele has also written that “no data of any sort support the idea that addiction is a characteristic of some mood-altering substances and not of others.”

“Those with better things to do,” Peele writes, “are protected from addiction.”

Andrew Weil, a well-known drug authority and author of The Natural Mind, has also objected to the “grossly materialistic conceptions of addiction” offered up by proponents of the biochemical view.

A biological view of addiction can be a way of giving intractable addicts hope, researchers say. Peele, however, draws exactly the opposite conclusion, arguing that the disease model is telling addicts that there is no hope, that they cannot do anything about their incurable “disease.”

Considering all the basic qualifiers about biochemical theories that the researchers themselves felt obliged to use in the first place, it was galling in the extreme to have critics like Peele deriding the effort in its entirety--and most amazingly of all, bringing back the old bugaboo about controlled drinking. Adherents of the controlled drinking theory hold that alcoholics can frequently return to social, responsible drinking, without having to maintain total abstinence.

If an alcoholic limits himself to two or three drinks a day, and does it successfully for a period of time, this behavior looks from the outside like controlled drinking. Many alcoholics and other drug addicts are able to accomplish this feat for varying lengths of time. Indeed, AA members are familiar with this counterfeit form of controlled drinking, and even have a name for it: White-knuckle sobriety. Controlled drinking-- also known as sobriety without abstinence--is certainly not unheard of among alcoholics

But is it a practical response to

Alcoholism ?

Dr. Arnold Ludwig, professor of psychiatry at Kentucky University’s College of Medicine, disagrees. In his book, Understanding the Alcoholic’s Mind, Ludwig writes: “Those authors who argue that many can return to normal drinking fail to grasp an essential point: it is less frustrating for the preponderance of alcoholics to avoid drinking altogether than to settle for one normal-sized drink, such as a single martini, a glass of wine, or a beer.”

For most serious alcoholics, it is easier to abstain altogether, rather than to engage in controlled, responsible, non-intoxicated drinking.

The idea of controlled drinking (or controlled drug use) is the one hope almost every addict brings to his or her initial encounter with treatment. As one AA veteran put it: “If it were possible for a majority of alcoholics to revert to controlled drinking, every alcoholic in AA would have found out about it a long time ago.”

It sometimes seems as if critics like Stanton Peele are attempting to resurrect the moral view of the past, offering no new approaches while legitimizing the criminal penalties and social stigma that has been America’s response to addiction all along.

Sources:

Peele, Stanton. Diseasing of America. Jossey-Bass, 1999

Peele, Stanton. "A Moral Vision of Addiction: How People’s Values Determine Whether They Become and Remain Addicts,” Journal of Drug Issues, Vol. 17, Spring, 1987.

Ludwig, Arnold M., Understanding the Alcoholic's Mind. Oxford University Press, New York, 1988.

About the Author

http://www.blogger.com/profile/07429793255785560043
Dirk Hanson is a freelance science reporter and novelist who lives in Minnesota. His two previous books—The New Alchemists: Silicon Valley and the Microlectronics Revolution, and The Incursion: A Novel—were reviewed in the New York Times, The New Yorker, the Los Angeles Times, Fortune, and other publications. He has written for California Magazine, Omni, CoEvolution Quarterly, Willamette Week, the Whole Mind Newsletter, and other magazines. He has also worked as a business and technology reporter for the Des Moines Register and for numerous trade publications.

Ludwig LE-790 Bass Drum Stand $113.99 Ludwig LE-790 Bass Drum Stand

Ludwig LF-6741 Bass Drum Carrier $187.91 Ludwig LF-6741 Bass Drum Carrier

Ludwig LF-1741 Bass Drum Carrier $109.99 Ludwig LF-1741 Bass Drum Carrier

Ludwig Le-790 Bass Drum Stand $108.99 Ludwig LE-790 Bass Drum Stand

Ludwig Lf-1741 Bass Drum Carrier $109.99 Ludwig LF-1741 Bass Drum Carrier

Ludwig Lf-6741 Bass Drum Carrier $187.91 Ludwig LF-6741 Bass Drum Carrier

Used Ludwig Bass Pedal 0312 $19.99 In Store Used USED LUDWIG BASS PEDAL 0312

Ludwig Bass Drum Stabilizer $82 The Ludwig Bass Drum Stabilizer keeps your drum rock solid all night long.

Ludwig Marching Pit Stands For Bells Or Bass Drums $119.99 Ludwig Marching Pit Stands For Bells Or Bass Drums

Ludwig Marching Pit Stands Bass Drum Cradle $204.99 Ludwig Marching Pit Stands Bass Drum Cradle

Ludwig LF-350 Bass Drum Sling Black $29.99 Ludwig LF-350 Bass Drum Sling Black

Ludwig Marching Bass Drum Sling Cadet Black $39.99 Ludwig Marching Bass Drum Sling Cadet Black

Ludwig Centennial Bass Drum Natural Lacquer 22X20 $570.05 Ludwig Centennial Bass Drum Natural Lacquer 22X20

Ludwig Challenger Bass Drum White 20 Inch $492.99 Ludwig Challenger Bass Drum White 20 Inch

Ludwig LF-350 Bass Drum Sling White $29.99 Ludwig LF-350 Bass Drum Sling White

Ludwig LE-CB Bass Drum White 20x36 $759.99 Ludwig LE-CB Bass Drum White 20x36

Ludwig Clear Bass Drum Head 28 Inch $36.99 Ludwig Clear Bass Drum Head 28 Inch

Ludwig Lf-350 Bass Drum Sling Black $28.49 Ludwig LF-350 Bass Drum Sling Black

Ludwig Lf-350 Bass Drum Sling White $29.99 Ludwig LF-350 Bass Drum Sling White

Used Ludwig Accent 6Pc Double Bass Kit $369.99 In Store Used USED LUDWIG ACCENT 6PC DOUBLE BASS KIT

Used Ludwig Single Chain Bass Drum Pedal $29.99 In Store Used USED LUDWIG SINGLE CHAIN BASS DRUM PEDAL

Used Ludwig Speed King Bass Drum Pedal $49.99 In Store Used USED LUDWIG SPEED KING BASS DRUM PEDAL

Ludwig Legacy Classic Lacquer Bass Drum 18X24 Rose Gold Lacquer $1427 Ludwig Legacy Classic Lacquer Bass Drum 18X24 Rose Gold Lacquer

Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 28 Inch $38.99 Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 28 Inch

Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 24 Inch $35.99 Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 24 Inch

Ludwig Concert Bass Drum Mallet L-308 Payson Sostenuto $28.99 Ludwig Concert Bass Drum Mallet L-308 Payson Sostenuto

Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 22 Inch $34.99 Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 22 Inch

Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 36 Inch $53.99 Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 36 Inch

Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 30 Inch $42.99 Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 30 Inch

Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 32 Inch $44.99 Ludwig LW4200 Smooth White Bass Drum Head 32 Inch